Hello dear
Welcome To Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, located in Ontario, NY, is renowned for its welcoming atmosphere and exceptional customer service. Patrons rave about the friendly staff, who are quick to address any concerns while maintaining a positive vibe. The pizzeria prides itself on generous portions of classic dishes, including mouthwatering subs and delicious pizzas, often made with humor and care. Despite occasional lunch rushes that might leave you waiting for a slice, the quality and flavor remain consistent. With a commitment to delighting customers, Salvatore's is a must-visit for anyone craving comforting, hearty Italian fare.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Fries
US$6.75Double Burger
US$11.95Haddock Fish Fry
US$17.95
Big Bertha’s Fish Sub
US$15.95Grilled Veggie
Fish Fry Plate
Shaved Steak
Grilled Chicken
Chicken Fingers
About
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria
Welcome to Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled at 6200 County Line Rd in Ontario, NY. Known for its warm atmosphere and friendly service, this pizzeria has quickly built a reputation that goes beyond just mouthwatering pizza.
As soon as you step through the doors, you'll be greeted by a team that not only serves with skill but also makes every customer feel like part of the family. A review from Kara Farmer captures the spirit of this establishment perfectly, noting the staff’s willingness to resolve any issues with a smile and a dash of humor. It's not just about the food; it’s the experience that keeps diners coming back. The management's hands-on approach ensures that every dish meets high-quality standards, making each visit memorable.
The menu boasts a variety of offerings that stand out, particularly the subs, which have garnered rave reviews from patrons like Terri Bailey. She reminisces about the delicious, generously-sized subs she brought to her brother, highlighting the consistent quality that Salvatore's delivers, even after a long journey. These hearty subs are not to be overlooked—they are a testament to the skill and effort put into every meal.
But let’s not forget the crown jewel—Salvatore's pizza! Though there have been mixed experiences with availability during lunch hours, customers like Josh Kaplin affirm that the pizza is always worth the wait. Whether it's a classic cheese slice or a specialty pie, the love for pizza radiates from every bite. Each slice epitomizes the essence of what a good pizzeria should be—fresh ingredients, robust flavors, and a perfectly baked crust.
Of course, no food experience is without its minor hiccups. Dave “Doodles” Newman shared a noteworthy incident where an order mix-up didn’t tarnish his overall enjoyment. Rather, it showcased the staff’s commitment to rectify situations promptly, leaving customers satisfied and eager to return. This ability to adapt speaks volumes about the pizzeria's dedication to customer service.
Overall, Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria is more than just a place to grab a meal. It’s a community hub where flavors flourish, friendships are made, and every bite feels like a hug from the heart of Italy. Whether you're craving a slice of pizza, a hearty sub, or just a hearty laugh, Salvatore's is well worth a visit. Don’t forget to stop in, enjoy the ambiance, and taste the tradition!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ The Salvatore’s crew in Ontario, NY are the most friendliest people I’ve encountered in awhile when it comes to customer service. They are quick to fix any little mistakes that may have been made and don’t make a fuss out of it. The managers go above and beyond their duties as they are always there and they ensure good quality food. Also they crack good jokes most of the time which brighten the environment. Highly recommend stopping in and getting some food. You get what you pay for as the quantities are always plentiful. Keep up the good work! ”
“ My brother raves about your sub's so, I decided too pick up a couple and bring them up north to him. I ordered 2 large subs to go. We didn't get to eat them til 7PM. Let tell you those subs were delicious. I'll definitely be getting another sub from you in the future!!!! ”
“ It's hit or miss lunch hour rather they have slices or not. I've had days I've waited 20 min in line to get a slice and they completely out of them and I've had days where it's a ghost town and it's in and out. But the pizza has always been good! ”
“ Good food, good service, good people. Always good! ”
“ I had to give all 4 stars... would've been 5 if I received the correct order. 2 subs, 1 was wrong didn't know it till I got to where we were staying, which fortunately was 3 mins away. Immediately went back kindly said "Wrong sandwich", the guy rattled off what I had ordered and I said "Nope". At that point he took the wrong sandwich and made me the right one, even meatier. So it was quick but I had to go back, had it been a longer ride, less stars. *NOTE: Read the receipt b4 leaving. Other than that a little pricey, product is good. ”
“ The best Salvatores location by far. Very friendly staff, fast service and incredible pizza! ”
“ Hands down the best chicken Charlie pizza we've ever had from any salvatores location. We placed the order online for pick up and it was ready exactly when it was suppose to be. The dining area was clean and spacious, parking was plentiful and the service was great! ”
“ We order out from Salvatore's just about every Thursday and the service is always quick and efficient and the food has been made to order with no mistakes and everything has been tasty! We order (mostly) subs and pick up ”